23,036,271
Vote Records
25,695
Companies
11,771
Funds
3,902
Managers

Home › Companies › AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. › 2023-2024

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. 2023-2024 Proxy Voting Records

Download data (CSV): ballot items · votes by manager · column guide.

Compiled from SEC Form N-PX filings and AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s Form 8-K, filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07 on EDGAR). Page generated November 20, 2026.

  • 14Ballot items
  • 456Asset managers, any item
  • 7,239Fund votes
  • May 23, 2024Meeting date

Results at a glance

Meeting of May 23, 2024: 14 items on AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s Form 8-K, filed May 24, 2024: 14 passed (calculated).

Dissent

Notable dissent: 1 director (15.5% against).

Dissent tiers, on the company’s own Form 8-K tally (support = FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST), or FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD) on a withhold ballot; abstentions and broker non-votes excluded): shareholder proposals with 15% support or more are notable, 25% significant, 40% high; director nominees with 10% or more against or withheld are notable, 20% significant; say-on-pay under 80% support is notable, under 70% significant; equity and compensation plans with 15% or more against are notable, 25% significant; any other item the board put forward with 15% or more against is notable. How this is decided

Proxy season: 2023-2024 2024-2025 2025-2026

Explore AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. in the interactive database Compare manager voting policies

Official 2023-2024 meeting results reported by AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.

These tallies are AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own, as disclosed to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on Form 8-K, filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07, “Submission of Matters to a Vote of Security Holders”). They cover every share voted at the meeting, not just the funds that file Form N-PX.

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. — official shareholder meeting results, meeting held May 23, 2024
Ballot itemForAgainst AbstainWithheldBroker non-votesSupport (of votes cast)Reported outcomeVoting standard
Elect Director: Carl H. Lindner III 73,511,970---- 1,453,0432,806,295 98%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: S. Craig Lindner 73,511,614---- 1,453,3992,806,295 98%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: John B. Berding 70,282,004---- 4,683,0092,806,295 94%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: James E. Evans 67,932,238---- 7,032,7752,806,295 91%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: Gregory G. Joseph 70,929,045---- 4,035,9682,806,295 95%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: Mary Beth Martin 72,283,426---- 2,681,5872,806,295 96%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: Amy Y. Murray 74,537,263---- 427,7502,806,295 99.4%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: Roger K. Newport 74,812,521---- 152,4922,806,295 99.8%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: Evans N. Nwankwo 72,437,757---- 2,527,2562,806,295 97%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: William W. Verity 63,324,667---- 11,640,3462,806,295 84%Passed (calculated)—
Elect Director: John I. Von Lehman 71,905,524---- 3,059,4892,806,295 96%Passed (calculated)—
2. Ratify the appointment of Ernst & Young LLP as the Company's independent registered public accounting firm for 2024 75,889,7141,831,78249,812 ---- 98%Passed (calculated)—
3. Approve, on an advisory basis, the compensation of the Company's named executive officers 71,269,6043,619,78975,620 --2,806,295 95%Passed (calculated)—
4. Approve the Amended and Restated 2015 Stock Incentive Plan 72,775,9792,076,045112,989 --2,806,295 97%Passed (calculated)—

Source: AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., Form 8-K, filed with the SEC on May 24, 2024 — read the filing on EDGAR.

How asset managers voted at the AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. 2023-2024 meeting

456 asset managers disclosed a vote on at least one AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. item in their SEC Form N-PX filings. Each item below shows how many of them voted on it, and how. Share totals are the shares those managers' funds voted, summed across every fund they report.

Elect Director: John I. Von Lehman

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 7 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

96% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 96%
FOR: 71,905,524WITHHELD: 3,059,489
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 114 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: John I. Von Lehman

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: John I. Von Lehman”): 71,905,524 for, 3,059,489 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 96% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 114 asset managers below reported 28,899,169 for, 482,217 withheld, 19,461 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 28,899,169ABSTAIN: 19,461WITHHOLD: 482,217
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: John I. Von Lehman” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,6520 0276For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance00 0165,300Withhold
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS00 0152,355Withhold
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 114 asset managers. All 114 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Amy Y. Murray

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.4% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.4%
FOR: 74,537,263WITHHELD: 427,750
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: Amy Y. Murray

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Amy Y. Murray”): 74,537,263 for, 427,750 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 99.4% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 29,372,824 for, 25,002 withheld, 1,501 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 29,372,824ABSTAIN: 1,501WITHHOLD: 25,002
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: Amy Y. Murray” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,8160 0112For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS152,3550 00For
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Carl H. Lindner III

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

98% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 98%
FOR: 73,511,970WITHHELD: 1,453,043
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: Carl H. Lindner III

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Carl H. Lindner III”): 73,511,970 for, 1,453,043 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 98% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 29,354,552 for, 27,744 withheld, 17,031 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 29,354,552ABSTAIN: 17,031WITHHOLD: 27,744
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: Carl H. Lindner III” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,7460 0182For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS152,3550 00For
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Evans N. Nwankwo

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

97% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 97%
FOR: 72,437,757WITHHELD: 2,527,256
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: Evans N. Nwankwo

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Evans N. Nwankwo”): 72,437,757 for, 2,527,256 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 97% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 28,987,044 for, 392,985 withheld, 19,298 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 28,987,044ABSTAIN: 19,298WITHHOLD: 392,985
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: Evans N. Nwankwo” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,7220 0206For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance00 0165,300Withhold
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS00 0152,355Withhold
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Gregory G. Joseph

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

95% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 95%
FOR: 70,929,045WITHHELD: 4,035,968
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: Gregory G. Joseph

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Gregory G. Joseph”): 70,929,045 for, 4,035,968 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 95% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 28,623,324 for, 758,972 withheld, 17,031 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 28,623,324ABSTAIN: 17,031WITHHOLD: 758,972
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: Gregory G. Joseph” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street1,0200 0573,908Withhold
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS152,3550 00For
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: James E. Evans

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

91% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 91%
FOR: 67,932,238WITHHELD: 7,032,775
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: James E. Evans

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: James E. Evans”): 67,932,238 for, 7,032,775 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 91% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 27,491,793 for, 1,371,071 withheld, 536,463 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 27,491,793ABSTAIN: 536,463WITHHOLD: 1,371,071
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: James E. Evans” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,737,1580 061,100For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street1,0200 0573,908Withhold
Charles Schwab00 0452,361Withhold
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.00 335,9920Abstain
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS152,3550 00For
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: John B. Berding

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

94% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 94%
FOR: 70,282,004WITHHELD: 4,683,009
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: John B. Berding

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: John B. Berding”): 70,282,004 for, 4,683,009 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 94% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 28,351,064 for, 922,381 withheld, 125,882 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 28,351,064ABSTAIN: 125,882WITHHOLD: 922,381
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: John B. Berding” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street1,0200 0573,908Withhold
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National65,0240 109,0140Mixed
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS152,3550 00For
WisdomTree00 0142,816Withhold
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Mary Beth Martin

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

96% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 96%
FOR: 72,283,426WITHHELD: 2,681,587
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: Mary Beth Martin

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Mary Beth Martin”): 72,283,426 for, 2,681,587 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 96% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 28,979,950 for, 402,346 withheld, 17,031 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 28,979,950ABSTAIN: 17,031WITHHOLD: 402,346
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: Mary Beth Martin” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,7220 0206For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance00 0165,300Withhold
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS00 0152,355Withhold
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Roger K. Newport

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.8% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.8%
FOR: 74,812,521WITHHELD: 152,492
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: Roger K. Newport

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Roger K. Newport”): 74,812,521 for, 152,492 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 99.8% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 29,372,826 for, 24,837 withheld, 1,664 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 29,372,826ABSTAIN: 1,664WITHHOLD: 24,837
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: Roger K. Newport” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,9280 00For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS152,3550 00For
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: S. Craig Lindner

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

98% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 98%
FOR: 73,511,614WITHHELD: 1,453,399
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: S. Craig Lindner

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: S. Craig Lindner”): 73,511,614 for, 1,453,399 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 98% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 29,354,552 for, 27,744 withheld, 17,031 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 29,354,552ABSTAIN: 17,031WITHHOLD: 27,744
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: S. Craig Lindner” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,7460 0182For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS152,3550 00For
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: William W. Verity

Calculated outcomeDIRECTOR ELECTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 6 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

84% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 84%WITHHELD
FOR: 63,324,667WITHHELD: 11,640,346
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 113 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Election of Directors: William W. Verity

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: William W. Verity”): 63,324,667 for, 11,640,346 withheld, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts using a plurality of the votes cast, the standard stated in the company’s proxy statement: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 84% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 113 asset managers below reported 25,915,351 for, 2,747,245 withheld, 736,731 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 25,915,351ABSTAIN: 736,731WITHHOLD: 2,747,245
Largest asset managers voting on “Election of Directors: William W. Verity” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,686,8360 0111,422For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street9260 0574,002Withhold
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.00 335,9920Abstain
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein00 0273,753Withhold
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA00 0248,894Withhold
Voya00 0226,747Withhold
Jackson National65,0240 109,0140Mixed
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance00 0165,300Withhold
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS00 0152,355Withhold
WisdomTree00 0142,816Withhold
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle00 0132,659Withhold
Equitable41,5980 084,651Mixed

Showing the 25 largest of 113 asset managers. All 113 are in the interactive database (link above).

Approve the Amended and Restated 2015 Stock Incentive Plan

Calculated outcomeCOMPENSATIONPassed (calculated)

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

97% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 97%
FOR: 72,775,979AGAINST: 2,076,045
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 123 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: APPROVAL OF THE AMENDED AND RESTATED 2015 STOCK INCENTIVE PLAN.

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“4. Approve the Amended and Restated 2015 Stock Incentive Plan”): 72,775,979 for, 2,076,045 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 97% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 123 asset managers below reported 29,185,949 for, 234,568 against, 34,938 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 29,185,949AGAINST: 234,568ABSTAIN: 34,938
Largest asset managers voting on “APPROVAL OF THE AMENDED AND RESTATED 2015 STOCK INCENTIVE PLAN.” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,85870 00For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS152,3550 00For
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 123 asset managers. All 123 are in the interactive database (link above).

Approve, on an advisory basis, the compensation of the Company's named executive officers

Calculated outcomeFund totals may overlapEXTRAORDINARY TRANSACTIONSEXTRAORDINARY TRANSACTIONSEXTRAORDINARY TRANSACTIONSEXTRAORDINARY TRANSACTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 9 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

95% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 95%
FOR: 71,269,604AGAINST: 3,619,789
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 455 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Advisory vote on compensation of named executive officers.

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“3. Approve, on an advisory basis, the compensation of the Company's named executive officers”): 71,269,604 for, 3,619,789 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 95% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

Fund voting reports and institutional-manager reports both cover this item. An institutional manager can report shares that a fund it advises also reports, so the two are shown separately below and never added together, and their sum is not shown (fund and manager reports combined may count the same shares twice).

Fund voting reports: 114 asset managers voting on “Advisory vote on compensation of named executive officers.” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,85870 00For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National65,024109,014 00Mixed
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS0152,355 00Against
WisdomTree0142,816 00Against
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Fund voting reports, all 114 managers: 28,862,661 for, 541,874 against, 26,338 abstained. Showing the 25 largest; every one is in the interactive database (link above).

Institutional-manager reports: 368 asset managers voting on “Advisory vote on compensation of named executive officers.” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Fidelity5,440,1370 00For
Victory Capital3,820,2901,839 00For
BlackRock2,859,199415 00For
State Street2,236,00827,570 00For
GEODE CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, LLC1,309,5950 00For
AllianceBernstein977,8350 00For
Man Group plc0823,180 00Against
Invesco809,7160 00For
LSV ASSET MANAGEMENT688,73021,200 00For
FORT WASHINGTON INVESTMENT ADVISORS INC /OH/601,4310 00For
MELLON INVESTMENTS Corp28585,214 00Against
Northern Trust558,7904,875 00For
JOHNSON INVESTMENT COUNSEL INC556,1400 00For
Goldman Sachs464,7220 00For
Charles Schwab456,5490 00For
JARISLOWSKY, FRASER Ltd438,6750 00For
LORD, ABBETT & CO. LLC366,0310 00For
BAHL & GAYNOR INC345,140166 00For
Wealthquest Corp343,3600 00For
Dimensional290,4670 00For
Voya286,0220 00For
Nuveen263,3640 00For
PRINCIPAL GLOBAL INVESTORS251,8310 00For
Point72242,4330 00For
Eaton Vance215,3000 00For

Institutional-manager reports, all 368 managers: 28,025,978 for, 3,053,223 against, 3 withheld, 886 abstained, 823 not voted, 9 unknown. Showing the 25 largest; every one is in the interactive database (link above).

Ratify the appointment of Ernst & Young LLP as the Company's independent registered public accounting firm for 2024

Calculated outcomeEXTRAORDINARY TRANSACTIONSEXTRAORDINARY TRANSACTIONSEXTRAORDINARY TRANSACTIONSEXTRAORDINARY TRANSACTIONSPassed (calculated)

Combines 5 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

98% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 98%
FOR: 75,889,714AGAINST: 1,831,782
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 120 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: Proposal to ratify the Audit Committee's appointment of Ernst & Young LLP as the Company's Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm for 2024.

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“2. Ratify the appointment of Ernst & Young LLP as the Company's independent registered public accounting firm for 2024”): 75,889,714 for, 1,831,782 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 24, 2024 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Outcome: Passed (calculated) — The company’s filing reports the vote counts but does not state the outcome; we calculated it from the counts: votes for exceeded votes against.
Support: 98% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 120 asset managers below reported 29,415,363 for, 417 against, 26,338 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 29,415,363AGAINST: 417ABSTAIN: 26,338
Largest asset managers voting on “Proposal to ratify the Audit Committee's appointment of Ernst & Young LLP as the Company's Independent Registe” at AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC., 2023-2024
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard7,953,1370 00For
Fidelity5,798,2580 00For
BlackRock4,386,3570 00For
Victory Capital2,737,7100 00For
Invesco762,4950 00For
Dimensional735,8130 00For
State Street574,85870 00For
Charles Schwab452,3610 00For
Principal424,3170 00For
Lord Abbett343,0840 00For
Value Line Mid Cap Focused Fund, Inc.335,9920 00For
First Trust330,4010 00For
AllianceBernstein273,7530 00For
ProShares250,6370 00For
TIAA248,8940 00For
Voya226,7470 00For
Jackson National174,0380 00For
Goldman Sachs171,2870 00For
Eaton Vance165,3000 00For
Brighthouse164,1230 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS152,3550 00For
WisdomTree142,8160 00For
AIG/SunAmerica138,6730 00For
Columbia Threadneedle132,6590 00For
Equitable126,2490 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 120 asset managers. All 120 are in the interactive database (link above).

Largest AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. shareholders voting in 2023-2024

Ranked separately for each type of Form N-PX report. An institutional manager can report shares that a fund it advises also reports, so the two tables can list the same shares and are never added together. Each is ranked by the shares voted on the item that the most managers of that type reported, shown as a share of the 83,857,354 shares outstanding at the time of that meeting.

Fund voting reports: top AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. shareholders by shares voted on “Advisory vote on compensation of named executive officers.”, 2023-2024
#Asset manager % of shares outstanding
1Vanguard 9.48%
2Fidelity 6.91%
3BlackRock 5.23%
4Victory Capital 3.26%
5Invesco 0.91%
6Dimensional 0.88%
7State Street 0.69%
8Charles Schwab 0.54%
9Principal 0.51%
10Lord Abbett 0.41%
Institutional-manager reports: top AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. shareholders by shares voted on “Advisory vote on compensation of named executive officers.”, 2023-2024
#Asset manager % of shares outstanding
1Fidelity 6.49%
2Victory Capital 4.56%
3BlackRock 3.41%
4State Street 2.70%
5GEODE CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, LLC 1.56%
6AllianceBernstein 1.17%
7Man Group plc 0.98%
8Invesco 0.97%
9LSV ASSET MANAGEMENT 0.85%
10FORT WASHINGTON INVESTMENT ADVISORS INC /OH/ 0.72%

Reported AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. holdings and ownership

As disclosed to the SEC in Form 13F (quarter-end holdings of 30 large managers), Schedules 13D and 13G (beneficial ownership above 5%) and the company’s own proxy statement (DEF 14A). Each row gives its source and the date its figure is as of: for Form 13F the quarter end it reports, for Schedules 13D and 13G the filing date, and for the proxy statement the date of its ownership table (or, where that date has not been read, the date the proxy was filed). The rows are therefore not all as of the same day.

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. holdings and ownership disclosed for the 2023-2024 proxy season, with each row’s source and date
HolderShares % outstandingSource, as of
Vanguard Group7,391,788 8.81%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2024
BlackRock7,292,671 8.70%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2024
FMR (Fidelity)6,913,544 8.24%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2024
Carl H. Lindner III5,553,409 6.62%Proxy statement (DEF 14A), proxy filed April 4, 2024
FMR, LLC5,121,287 6.11%Proxy statement (DEF 14A), proxy filed April 4, 2024
S. Craig Lindner5,020,500 5.99%Proxy statement (DEF 14A), proxy filed April 4, 2024
State Street2,571,205 3.07%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2024
David L. Thompson, Jr.1,680,119 2.00%Proxy statement (DEF 14A), proxy filed April 4, 2024
Geode Capital1,333,368 1.59%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2024
Dimensional Fund Advisors1,055,367 1.26%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2024

Percentages above are of 83,857,354 shares outstanding, as reported by AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. on its Form 10-Q dated March 31, 2024 (see the filing on EDGAR). This is the count contemporaneous with the 2023-2024 meeting, not today’s. Each holding is as of its own filing, which may be dated before or after the meeting.

About this meeting

At AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.'s shareholder meeting held May 23, 2024, in the 2023-2024 proxy season, 456 asset managers reported votes on at least one of its 14 ballot items in their SEC Form N-PX filings, covering 7,239 separate fund positions. On the most widely held item on that ballot — Advisory vote on compensation of named executive officers. — FOR was 95% of the votes cast (FOR divided by FOR plus AGAINST, the conventional basis for proxy support; abstentions, broker non-votes and unvoted shares are excluded because none of them took a side), which is more than half. Whether the item was approved is for the filing to say; that statement has not been read for this item. Source: AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.'s Form 8-K, Item 5.07, filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on May 24, 2024.

Related

About this page

Every figure above is derived from filings made with the US Securities and Exchange Commission: Form N-PX, in which registered funds disclose how they voted every proxy and institutional managers disclose their votes on executive pay (say-on-pay, say-on-frequency and golden parachutes), and Form 8-K Item 5.07, in which the company reports its own meeting results. Shares outstanding are taken from AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC.’s 10-Q dated March 31, 2024. This page is a static snapshot rebuilt weekly on November 20, 2026; a live search always shows the current data.

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC. proxy season coverage: 2023-2024 (this page) · 2024-2025 · 2025-2026.

Cite this page

Proxy Votes Now, “AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP (AFG) 2024 Annual Meeting: Vote Results”, https://proxyvotesnow.com/company/american-financial-group-inc/2024 (version of November 20, 2026). Derived from SEC Form N-PX and Form 8-K filings; tables licensed CC BY 4.0. Licence: CC BY 4.0.