22,135,656
Vote Records
28,570
Companies
12,092
Funds
3,981
Managers

Home › Companies › SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. › 2024-2025

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. 2024-2025 Proxy Voting Records

Download data (CSV): ballot items · votes by manager · column guide.

Compiled from SEC Form N-PX filings and SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s Form 8-K, filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07 on EDGAR). Page generated November 20, 2026.

  • 14Ballot items
  • 361Asset managers, any item
  • 6,170Fund votes
  • April 30, 2025Meeting date

Results at a glance

Meeting of April 30, 2025: 14 items on SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s Form 8-K, filed May 1, 2025: 12 elected · 2 approved.

Dissent

No notable dissent.

Dissent tiers, on the company’s own Form 8-K tally (support = FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST), or FOR ÷ (FOR + WITHHELD) on a withhold ballot; abstentions and broker non-votes excluded): shareholder proposals with 15% support or more are notable, 25% significant, 40% high; director nominees with 10% or more against or withheld are notable, 20% significant; say-on-pay under 80% support is notable, under 70% significant; equity and compensation plans with 15% or more against are notable, 25% significant; any other item the board put forward with 15% or more against is notable. How this is decided

Proxy season: 2023-2024 2024-2025 2025-2026

Explore SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. in the interactive database Compare manager voting policies

Official 2024-2025 meeting results reported by SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.

These tallies are SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own, as disclosed to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on Form 8-K, filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07, “Submission of Matters to a Vote of Security Holders”). They cover every share voted at the meeting, not just the funds that file Form N-PX.

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. — official shareholder meeting results, meeting held April 30, 2025
Ballot itemForAgainst AbstainWithheldBroker non-votesSupport (of votes cast)Reported outcomeVoting standard
Elect Director: Ainar D. Aijala, Jr. 49,009,037319,13239,989 --4,270,734 99.4%Elected—
Elect Director: Lisa Rojas Bacus 48,880,422433,91253,824 --4,270,734 99.1%Elected—
Elect Director: Terrence W. Cavanaugh 49,249,15351,80667,199 --4,270,734 99.9%Elected—
Elect Director: Wole C. Coaxum 48,965,232362,38640,540 --4,270,734 99.3%Elected—
Elect Director: Robert Kelly Doherty 49,095,320233,73539,103 --4,270,734 99.5%Elected—
Elect Director: John J. Marchioni 48,009,2851,322,85836,015 --4,270,734 97%Elected—
Elect Director: Thomas A. McCarthy 49,105,891222,15840,109 --4,270,734 99.5%Elected—
Elect Director: Stephen C. Mills 48,941,356373,02753,775 --4,270,734 99.2%Elected—
Elect Director: H. Elizabeth Mitchell 49,119,235206,67042,253 --4,270,734 99.6%Elected—
Elect Director: Cynthia S. Nicholson 47,612,0531,716,14039,965 --4,270,734 97%Elected—
Elect Director: Kate E. R. Sampson 49,263,23664,95739,965 --4,270,734 99.9%Elected—
Elect Director: John S. Scheid 48,924,020403,29440,844 --4,270,734 99.2%Elected—
Company's stockholders voted to approve, on an advisory basis, the 2024 compensation of the named executive officers as disclosed in the Proxy Statement 47,733,8831,461,754172,521 --4,270,734 97%Approved—
Company's stockholders voted to ratify the appointment of KPMG LLP as the Company's independent registered public accounting firm for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2025 52,894,273667,21977,400 --0 99%Approved—

Source: SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., Form 8-K, filed with the SEC on May 1, 2025 — read the filing on EDGAR.

How asset managers voted at the SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. 2024-2025 meeting

361 asset managers disclosed a vote on at least one SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. item in their SEC Form N-PX filings. Each item below shows how many of them voted on it, and how. Share totals are the shares those managers' funds voted, summed across every fund they report.

Elect Director: Ainar D. Aijala, Jr.

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.4% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.4%
FOR: 49,009,037AGAINST: 319,132

Prior year: 97.8% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▲ 1.5 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: AINAR D. AIJALA, JR.

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Ainar D. Aijala, Jr.”): 49,009,037 for, 319,132 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.4% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,628,450 for, 6,517 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,628,450AGAINST: 6,517ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: AINAR D. AIJALA, JR.” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Cynthia S. Nicholson

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

97% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 97%
FOR: 47,612,053AGAINST: 1,716,140

Prior year: 89.7% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▲ 6.8 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: CYNTHIA S. NICHOLSON

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Cynthia S. Nicholson”): 47,612,053 for, 1,716,140 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 97% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,051,787 for, 583,180 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,051,787AGAINST: 583,180ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: CYNTHIA S. NICHOLSON” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,49826 00For
Calvert0559,165 00Against
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust331,11513,831 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: H. Elizabeth Mitchell

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.6% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.6%
FOR: 49,119,235AGAINST: 206,670

Prior year: 99.4% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▲ 0.2 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: H. ELIZABETH MITCHELL

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: H. Elizabeth Mitchell”): 49,119,235 for, 206,670 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.6% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,632,742 for, 0 against, 13,429 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,632,742AGAINST: 0ABSTAIN: 13,429
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: H. ELIZABETH MITCHELL” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: John J. Marchioni

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

97% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 97%
FOR: 48,009,285AGAINST: 1,322,858

Prior year: 97.6% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▼ 0.2 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: JOHN J. MARCHIONI

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: John J. Marchioni”): 48,009,285 for, 1,322,858 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 97% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,634,685 for, 282 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,634,685AGAINST: 282ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: JOHN J. MARCHIONI” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,50420 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: John S. Scheid

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.2% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.2%
FOR: 48,924,020AGAINST: 403,294

Prior year: 99.7% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▼ 0.5 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: JOHN S. SCHEID

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: John S. Scheid”): 48,924,020 for, 403,294 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.2% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,629,234 for, 5,733 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,629,234AGAINST: 5,733ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: JOHN S. SCHEID” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Kate E. R. Sampson

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.9% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.9%
FOR: 49,263,236AGAINST: 64,957
Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: KATE E. R. SAMPSON

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Kate E. R. Sampson”): 49,263,236 for, 64,957 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.9% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,634,182 for, 785 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,634,182AGAINST: 785ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: KATE E. R. SAMPSON” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Lisa Rojas Bacus

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.1% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.1%
FOR: 48,880,422AGAINST: 433,912

Prior year: 98.7% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▲ 0.5 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: LISA ROJAS BACUS

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Lisa Rojas Bacus”): 48,880,422 for, 433,912 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.1% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,626,224 for, 8,743 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,626,224AGAINST: 8,743ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: LISA ROJAS BACUS” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Robert Kelly Doherty

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.5% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.5%
FOR: 49,095,320AGAINST: 233,735

Prior year: 99.8% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▼ 0.3 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: ROBERT KELLY DOHERTY

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Robert Kelly Doherty”): 49,095,320 for, 233,735 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.5% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,629,235 for, 5,732 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,629,235AGAINST: 5,732ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: ROBERT KELLY DOHERTY” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Stephen C. Mills

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.2% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.2%
FOR: 48,941,356AGAINST: 373,027

Prior year: 97.9% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▲ 1.3 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: STEPHEN C. MILLS

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Stephen C. Mills”): 48,941,356 for, 373,027 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.2% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,626,224 for, 8,743 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,626,224AGAINST: 8,743ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: STEPHEN C. MILLS” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Terrence W. Cavanaugh

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.9% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.9%
FOR: 49,249,153AGAINST: 51,806

Prior year: 99.8% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▲ 0.1 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: TERRENCE W. CAVANAUGH

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Terrence W. Cavanaugh”): 49,249,153 for, 51,806 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.9% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,634,967 for, 0 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,634,967AGAINST: 0ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: TERRENCE W. CAVANAUGH” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Thomas A. McCarthy

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.5% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.5%
FOR: 49,105,891AGAINST: 222,158

Prior year: 99.8% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▼ 0.3 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: THOMAS A. MCCARTHY

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Thomas A. McCarthy”): 49,105,891 for, 222,158 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.5% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,634,967 for, 0 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,634,967AGAINST: 0ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: THOMAS A. MCCARTHY” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Elect Director: Wole C. Coaxum

Official resultDIRECTOR ELECTIONSReported outcome: Elected

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99.3% Majority: yes · of votes cast

FOR 99.3%
FOR: 48,965,232AGAINST: 362,386

Prior year: 99.8% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▼ 0.5 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: WOLE C. COAXUM

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Elect Director: Wole C. Coaxum”): 48,965,232 for, 362,386 against, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07). FOR was more than half of the votes cast. Whether the item passed is for the filing to say; its statement has not been read for this item.

Reported outcome: Elected, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders elected each of the twelve director nominees to serve on the Board of Directors for a term of one year, as follows:”
Support: 99.3% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,634,966 for, 1 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,634,966AGAINST: 1ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “ELECTION OF DIRECTORS: WOLE C. COAXUM” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,6370 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Company's stockholders voted to approve, on an advisory basis, the 2024 compensation of the named executive officers as…

Official resultFund totals may overlapCOMPENSATIONReported outcome: Approved

Combines 15 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

97% Approved · of votes cast

FOR 97%
FOR: 47,733,883AGAINST: 1,461,754

Prior year: 99.2% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▼ 2.2 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 361 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: APPROVAL, ON AN ADVISORY BASIS, OF THE 2024 COMPENSATION OF OUR NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Proposal 2: The Company's stockholders voted to approve, on an advisory basis, the 2024 compensation of the named executive officers as disclosed in the Proxy Statement, as follows:”): 47,733,883 for, 1,461,754 against — passed, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07).

Reported outcome: Approved, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders voted to approve, on an advisory basis, the 2024 compensation of the named executive officers as disclosed in the Proxy Statement, as follows:”
Support: 97% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

Fund voting reports and institutional-manager reports both cover this item. An institutional manager can report shares that a fund it advises also reports, so the two are shown separately below and never added together, and their sum is not shown (fund and manager reports combined may count the same shares twice).

Fund voting reports: 105 asset managers voting on “APPROVAL, ON AN ADVISORY BASIS, OF THE 2024 COMPENSATION OF OUR NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,903,262375 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,5240 00For
Calvert0559,165 00Against
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Fund voting reports, all 105 managers: 26,068,573 for, 566,394 against, 11,204 abstained. Showing the 25 largest; every one is in the interactive database (link above).

Institutional-manager reports: 287 asset managers voting on “APPROVAL, ON AN ADVISORY BASIS, OF THE 2024 COMPENSATION OF OUR NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Fidelity5,331,1760 00For
BlackRock2,554,376295 00For
State Street2,280,2290 00For
GEODE CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, LLC1,568,9660 00For
MACQUARIE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT BUSINESS TRUST1,400,4690 00For
VAUGHAN NELSON INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, L.P.940,5590 00For
Charles Schwab895,9440 00For
Northern Trust837,0610 00For
ATLANTA CAPITAL MANAGEMENT CO L L C646,4610 00For
Calvert0606,663 00Against
Boston Trust Walden Co513,4060 00For
Point72496,1230 00For
MELLON INVESTMENTS Corp490,2150 00For
MASSACHUSETTS FINANCIAL SERVICES CO /MA/479,6470 00For
EAGLE ASSET MANAGEMENT INC461,7710 00For
JACOBS LEVY EQUITY MANAGEMENT, INC447,3020 00For
Nuveen391,0100 00For
JPMorgan334,8990 00For
Dimensional279,6890 00For
SILVERCREST ASSET MANAGEMENT GROUP LLC276,9300 00For
Invesco242,5140 00For
T. Rowe Price237,6020 00For
CALIFORNIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES RETIREMENT SYSTEM225,4840 00For
Verition Fund Management LLC217,3960 00For
Natixis216,9890 00For

Institutional-manager reports, all 287 managers: 27,358,119 for, 928,266 against, 14,455 abstained, 5,691 not voted. Showing the 25 largest; every one is in the interactive database (link above).

Company's stockholders voted to ratify the appointment of KPMG LLP as the Company's independent registered public…

Official resultAUDIT-RELATEDReported outcome: Approved

Combines 3 wordings of this item as funds reported it.

99% Approved · of votes cast

FOR 99%
FOR: 52,894,273AGAINST: 667,219

Prior year: 98.3% for (May 1, 2024 meeting) ▲ 0.4 pts

Details: description as filed, official tally, votes by 105 asset managers

Description as filed by funds: RATIFICATITON OF APPOINTMENT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s own tally for this item (“Proposal 3: The Company's stockholders voted to ratify the appointment of KPMG LLP as the Company's independent registered public accounting firm for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2025, as follows:”): 52,894,273 for, 667,219 against — passed, per its Form 8-K filed May 1, 2025 (Item 5.07).

Reported outcome: Approved, in the filing’s own words: “The Company's stockholders voted to ratify the appointment of KPMG LLP as the Company's independent registered public accounting firm for the fiscal year ending December 31, 2025, as follows:”
Support: 99% of votes cast — FOR ÷ (FOR + AGAINST); abstentions and broker non-votes are excluded.

The 105 asset managers below reported 26,626,511 for, 8,456 against, 11,204 abstained.

FOR
FOR: 26,626,511AGAINST: 8,456ABSTAIN: 11,204
Largest asset managers voting on “RATIFICATITON OF APPOINTMENT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM” at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC., 2024-2025
Asset managerForAgainst AbstainWithheldVote
Vanguard5,902,3111,326 00For
Fidelity5,492,6290 00For
BlackRock4,846,9430 00For
Delaware/Macquarie1,275,6960 00For
Dimensional975,8160 00For
Charles Schwab884,6760 00For
State Street613,49826 00For
Calvert559,1650 00For
First Trust557,8970 00For
BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS400,2770 00For
TIAA385,7160 00For
MFS355,3560 00For
Bridge Builder Trust344,9460 00For
Natixis344,6290 00For
Equitable241,1950 00For
JPMorgan206,4130 00For
Jackson National196,2890 00For
Tributary Funds, Inc.192,0530 00For
Principal178,4920 00For
WisdomTree157,2260 00For
MoA Funds Corp152,2980 00For
DWS149,6580 00For
Northern Trust145,6740 00For
T. Rowe Price118,4950 00For
Value Line Small Cap Opportunities Fund, Inc.110,1930 00For

Showing the 25 largest of 105 asset managers. All 105 are in the interactive database (link above).

Largest SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. shareholders voting in 2024-2025

Ranked separately for each type of Form N-PX report. An institutional manager can report shares that a fund it advises also reports, so the two tables can list the same shares and are never added together. Each is ranked by the shares voted on the item that the most managers of that type reported, shown as a share of the 60,859,948 shares outstanding at the time of that meeting.

Fund voting reports: top SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. shareholders by shares voted on “APPROVAL, ON AN ADVISORY BASIS, OF THE 2024 COMPENSATION OF OUR NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS”, 2024-2025
#Asset manager % of shares outstanding
1Vanguard 9.70%
2Fidelity 9.03%
3BlackRock 7.96%
4Delaware/Macquarie 2.10%
5Dimensional 1.60%
6Charles Schwab 1.45%
7State Street 1.01%
8Calvert 0.92%
9First Trust 0.92%
10BOSTON TRUST WALDEN FUNDS 0.66%
Institutional-manager reports: top SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. shareholders by shares voted on “APPROVAL, ON AN ADVISORY BASIS, OF THE 2024 COMPENSATION OF OUR NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS”, 2024-2025
#Asset manager % of shares outstanding
1Fidelity 8.76%
2BlackRock 4.20%
3State Street 3.75%
4GEODE CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, LLC 2.58%
5MACQUARIE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT BUSINESS TRUST 2.30%
6VAUGHAN NELSON INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, L.P. 1.55%
7Charles Schwab 1.48%
8Northern Trust 1.38%
9ATLANTA CAPITAL MANAGEMENT CO L L C 1.06%
10Calvert 1.00%

Reported SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. holdings and ownership

As disclosed to the SEC in Form 13F (quarter-end holdings of 30 large managers), Schedules 13D and 13G (beneficial ownership above 5%) and the company’s own proxy statement (DEF 14A). Each row gives its source and the date its figure is as of: for Form 13F the quarter end it reports, for Schedules 13D and 13G the filing date, and for the proxy statement the date of its ownership table (or, where that date has not been read, the date the proxy was filed). The rows are therefore not all as of the same day.

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. holdings and ownership disclosed for the 2024-2025 proxy season, with each row’s source and date
HolderShares % outstandingSource, as of
BlackRock7,683,632 12.63%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2025
Vanguard Group6,756,225 11.10%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2025
FMR (Fidelity)5,361,170 8.81%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2025
AQR Capital Management, LLC4,059,547 6.67%Schedule 13G, filed February 13, 2026
Vanguard Portfolio Management3,515,742 5.78%Schedule 13G, filed April 29, 2026
State Street2,496,011 4.10%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2025
Morgan Stanley1,851,154 3.04%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2025
Dimensional Fund Advisors1,282,325 2.11%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2025
Northern Trust1,032,328 1.70%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2025
Charles Schwab891,871 1.47%Form 13F, quarter ended March 31, 2025

Percentages above are of 60,859,948 shares outstanding, as reported by SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. on its Form 10-Q dated June 30, 2024 (see the filing on EDGAR). This is the count contemporaneous with the 2024-2025 meeting, not today’s. Each holding is as of its own filing, which may be dated before or after the meeting.

About this meeting

At SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.'s shareholder meeting held April 30, 2025, in the 2024-2025 proxy season, 361 asset managers reported votes on at least one of its 14 ballot items in their SEC Form N-PX filings, covering 6,170 separate fund positions. On the most widely held item on that ballot — APPROVAL, ON AN ADVISORY BASIS, OF THE 2024 COMPENSATION OF OUR NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS — SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.'s filing reports the proposal as approved, with 97% support of the votes cast (FOR divided by FOR plus AGAINST, the conventional basis for proxy support; abstentions, broker non-votes and unvoted shares are excluded because none of them took a side). Source: SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.'s Form 8-K, Item 5.07, filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission on May 1, 2025.

Related

About this page

Every figure above is derived from filings made with the US Securities and Exchange Commission: Form N-PX, in which registered funds disclose how they voted every proxy and institutional managers disclose their votes on executive pay (say-on-pay, say-on-frequency and golden parachutes), and Form 8-K Item 5.07, in which the company reports its own meeting results. Shares outstanding are taken from SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC.’s 10-Q dated June 30, 2024. This page is a static snapshot rebuilt weekly on November 20, 2026; a live search always shows the current data.

SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. proxy season coverage: 2023-2024 · 2024-2025 (this page) · 2025-2026.

Cite this page

Proxy Votes Now, “SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP (SIGI) 2025 Annual Meeting: Vote Results”, https://proxyvotesnow.com/company/selective-insurance-group-inc/2025 (version of November 20, 2026). Derived from SEC Form N-PX and Form 8-K filings; tables licensed CC BY 4.0. Licence: CC BY 4.0.