proxyvotesnow.com

Home › Asset managers › Compare 2023-2024 › Dimensional vs John Hancock

Dimensional vs John Hancock: how alike they voted, 2023-2024

93.6% When both took a single position, they voted the same way on 93.6% of 18,835 items (17,628 the same, 1,207 different). 1,139 items where at least one of them split its funds are listed separately below. Both voted on 19,974 items in all.

Dimensional 2023-2024 · John Hancock 2023-2024 · Download the item list (CSV)

By who put the item on the ballot. “Same position” = Same / (Same + Differ); split items are not in it. “Fund-level” is a second view over all common items: the chance that a fund of each manager, picked at random, voted the same way, which gives partial credit where a manager split.
Common itemsSame DifferSplit (not in %)Same position Fund-level
All ballot items 19,97417,6281,207 1,13993.6%90.7%
Board proposals 16,80214,8521,195 75592.6%90.1%
E&S shareholder proposals 265815 17994.2%59.7%
Other items 2,9072,6957 20599.7%97.1%

Where they did not vote alike

Everything Voted differently Split votes

All ballot items Board proposals E&S shareholder proposals Other items

184 items. “Voted differently”: each manager’s funds all voted one way, and the two ways differ. “Split”: at least one manager’s funds did not all vote the same way.

CompanyMeetingProposalOn the ballot from Board recommendedDimensionalJohn Hancock
KEURIG DR PEPPER INC. June 10, 2024 To vote on a stockholder proposal requesting additional reporting on plastic packaging, if properly presented at Annual Meeting.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
4 FOR, 2 AGAINST
KNIGHT-SWIFT TRANSPORTATION HOLDINGS INC May 14, 2024 Vote on a stockholder proposal regarding managing climate risk through science-based targets and transition planning
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
18 funds
Split
3 FOR, 3 AGAINST
L3HARRIS TECHNOLOGIES INC. April 19, 2024 Shareholder Proposal titled "Transparency in Lobbying"
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
6 FOR, 6 AGAINST
LENNAR CORP. April 10, 2024 Vote on a stockholder proposal requesting a report disclosing the Company's LGBTQ equity and inclusion efforts in its human capital management strategy.
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 14 AGAINST
Split
2 FOR, 15 AGAINST
LENNAR CORP. April 10, 2024 Vote on a stockholder proposal requesting a report disclosing the Company's political spending and related policies and procedures.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
17 funds
Split
13 FOR, 4 AGAINST
LENNAR CORP. April 10, 2024 Vote on a stockholder proposal requesting a report on the Company's plans to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 14 AGAINST
Split
15 FOR, 2 AGAINST
LOCKHEED MARTIN CORP. May 2, 2024 Stockholder Proposal Requesting a Report on Alignment of Political Activities with Human Rights Policy
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined AGAINST
13 funds
Split
5 FOR, 4 AGAINST
LULULEMON ATHLETICA INC. June 6, 2024 Shareholder proposal regarding a report on the impact of the production and sale of animal-derived products (if properly presented at the meeting).
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
1 FOR, 12 AGAINST
MARKEL GROUP INC. May 22, 2024 Shareholder proposal for a report on the Company's greenhouse gas emissions.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 13 AGAINST
Split
3 FOR, 1 AGAINST
MARRIOTT INTERNATIONAL INC. May 10, 2024 STOCKHOLDER RESOLUTION REQUESTING THE COMPANY ANNUALLY PREPARE A RACIAL AND GENDER PAY GAP REPORT
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
1 FOR, 10 AGAINST
Split
6 FOR, 6 AGAINST
MARRIOTT INTERNATIONAL INC. May 10, 2024 STOCKHOLDER RESOLUTION REQUESTING THE COMPANY COMMISSION A THIRD-PARTY CIVIL RIGHTS AUDIT
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
11 funds
Split
5 FOR, 7 AGAINST
MASTERCARD INC. June 18, 2024 Consideration of a stockholder proposal requesting a congruency report on privacy and human rights
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
14 funds
Split
1 FOR, 16 AGAINST
MASTERCARD INC. June 18, 2024 Consideration of a stockholder proposal requesting a human rights congruency report
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
14 funds
Split
16 AGAINST, 1 ABSTAIN
MASTERCARD INC. June 18, 2024 Consideration of a stockholder proposal requesting transparency in lobbying
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
14 funds
Split
8 FOR, 9 AGAINST
MATTEL INC. May 29, 2024 Stockholder proposal requesting additional disclosure regarding political contributions and expenditures.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
14 funds
Split
3 FOR, 4 AGAINST
MAXIMUS INC. March 12, 2024 Shareholder proposal regarding the commission of a third party assessment on the Company's commitment to freedom of association and collective bargaining rights.
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
4 FOR, 12 AGAINST
FOR
5 funds
MESA LABORATORIES INC. August 25, 2023 To approve the shareholder proposal to measure and annually present scope 1 through 3 greenhouse gas emissions.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 13 AGAINST
FOR
4 funds
METLIFE INC. June 18, 2024 Shareholder proposal requesting a third-party racial equity audit
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
17 funds
Split
4 FOR, 7 AGAINST
MICROCHIP TECHNOLOGY INC. August 22, 2023 Stockholder proposal requesting that our Board of Directors commission an independent third-party report, at reasonable expense and excluding proprietary information, on our due diligence process to determine whether our customers' use of our products contribute or are linked to violations of international law.
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
14 funds
Split
4 FOR, 4 AGAINST
MICROSOFT CORP. December 7, 2023 Mandate for Third-Party Political Reporting
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
1 FOR, 31 AGAINST
MICROSOFT CORP. December 7, 2023 Report on AI Misinformation and Disinformation
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
19 FOR, 13 AGAINST
MICROSOFT CORP. December 7, 2023 Report on Climate Risks to Retirement Plan Beneficiaries
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
4 FOR, 28 AGAINST
MICROSOFT CORP. December 7, 2023 Report on Data Operations in Human Rights Hotspots
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
1 FOR, 14 AGAINST
Split
16 FOR, 16 AGAINST
MICROSOFT CORP. December 7, 2023 Report on Risks of Weapons Development
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
8 FOR, 24 AGAINST
MICROSOFT CORP. December 7, 2023 Report on Tax Transparency
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
18 FOR, 14 AGAINST
MONDELEZ INTERNATIONAL INC. May 22, 2024 Shareholder proposal requesting Board adopt targets and publicly report quantitative metrics to eradicate child labor from cocoa supply chain;
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
5 FOR, 7 AGAINST
MONDELEZ INTERNATIONAL INC. May 22, 2024 Shareholder proposal requesting third-party report assessing effectiveness of implementation of human rights policy; and
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
7 FOR, 5 AGAINST
MORGAN STANLEY May 23, 2024 Shareholder proposal regarding transparency in lobbying
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
15 FOR, 7 AGAINST
MORGAN STANLEY May 23, 2024 Shareholder proposal requesting a clean energy supply financing ratio
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 13 AGAINST
Split
15 FOR, 7 AGAINST
NETFLIX INC. June 6, 2024 Stockholder proposal entitled, "Report on Netflix's Use of Artificial Intelligence," if properly presented at the meeting.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
11 funds
Split
6 FOR, 10 AGAINST
NIKE INC. September 12, 2023 To consider a shareholder proposal regarding Supplemental Pay Equity Disclosure, if properly presented at the meeting.
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 10 AGAINST
Split
8 FOR, 4 AGAINST
NIKE INC. September 12, 2023 To consider a shareholder proposal regarding a Supply Chain Management Report, if properly presented at the meeting.
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
13 funds
Split
7 FOR, 5 AGAINST
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORP. May 9, 2024 A Shareholder proposal regarding an annual report on lobbying activities, policies and communications.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Contested AGAINST
14 funds
Split
5 FOR, 3 AGAINST
NORTHROP GRUMMAN CORP. May 15, 2024 Shareholder proposal to annually conduct an evaluation and issue a report describing the alignment of the Company's political activities with its human rights policy.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
4 FOR, 3 AGAINST
OCCIDENTAL PETROLEUM CORP. May 2, 2024 Shareholder Proposal Requesting an Annual Report on Lobbying
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined AGAINST
16 funds
Split
5 FOR, 1 AGAINST
ORACLE CORP. November 15, 2023 Stockholder Proposal Regarding Pay Gap Report
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 11 AGAINST
FOR
16 funds
PACCAR INC April 30, 2024 Stockholder proposal regarding a report on climate-related policy engagement
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 14 AGAINST
Split
5 FOR, 1 AGAINST
PFIZER INC. April 25, 2024 Publish a Congruency Report on Political, Lobbying, Electioneering Expenditures
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
6 FOR, 8 AGAINST
PHILLIPS 66 May 15, 2024 Shareholder proposal requesting report analyzing the impact of the "System Change Scenario" on the Chemicals business.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
17 funds
Split
5 FOR, 5 AGAINST
PNC FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP INC. April 24, 2024 Shareholder proposal regarding report on risk management and implementation of PNC's Human Rights Statement in financing.
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
7 FOR, 5 AGAINST
PREFORMED LINE PRODUCTS CO. May 7, 2024 To vote on shareholder proposal requesting that the Board of Directors prepare a report by January 2025, at reasonable expense and omitting proprietary information, on steps the Company is taking to enhance board diversity; and
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
4 FOR, 16 AGAINST
FOR
4 funds
PROCTER & GAMBLE CO. October 10, 2023 Shareholder Proposal - Annual Report on Operations in China
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
13 funds
Split
1 FOR, 7 AGAINST
QUEST DIAGNOSTICS INC. May 16, 2024 Stockholder proposal regarding managing climate risk through science-based targets and transition planning
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 14 AGAINST
FOR
6 funds
ROSS STORES INC. May 22, 2024 To vote on a stockholder proposal regarding reporting on material value chain GHG emissions, if properly presented at the Annual Meeting.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 13 AGAINST
Split
6 FOR, 4 AGAINST
RTX CORP. May 2, 2024 Shareowner Proposal Requesting a Lobbying Transparency Report
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined AGAINST
15 funds
Split
12 FOR, 1 AGAINST
RTX CORP. May 2, 2024 Shareowner Proposal Requesting a Report on Full Value Chain Emissions Reduction Plan
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined Split
2 FOR, 13 AGAINST
Split
10 FOR, 3 AGAINST
RYDER SYSTEM INC. May 3, 2024 To vote, on an advisory basis, on a shareholder proposal regarding managing climate risk through science-based targets and transition planning.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 16 AGAINST
Split
6 FOR, 2 AGAINST
RYDER SYSTEM INC. May 3, 2024 To vote, on an advisory basis, on a shareholder proposal regarding the Company's climate change strategy and related impacts on employment.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
4 FOR, 15 AGAINST
FOR
8 funds
SEMPRA May 9, 2024 Shareholder proposal requesting a report on certain safety and environmental matters
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined AGAINST
11 funds
Split
7 FOR, 6 AGAINST
SKECHERS U.S.A. INC. May 23, 2024 Stockholder proposal requesting our company to publicly disclose a timeline for meeting and disclosing our value chain emissions.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
4 FOR, 12 AGAINST
FOR
5 funds
SKYWORKS SOLUTIONS INC. May 14, 2024 To approve a stockholder proposal regarding adoption of greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 14 AGAINST
Split
6 FOR, 1 AGAINST
SONOCO PRODUCTS CO. April 17, 2024 Advisory (non-binding) shareholder proposal regarding transparency in political spending.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
19 funds
Split
3 FOR, 3 AGAINST
SOUTHERN CO. May 22, 2024 Stockholder proposal regarding disclosing short-, medium-, and long-term operational GHG targets
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
8 funds
Split
7 FOR, 4 AGAINST
STARBUCKS CORP. March 13, 2024 Shareholder proposal requesting a report on human rights policies.
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Contested AGAINST
12 funds
Split
1 FOR, 8 AGAINST
STARBUCKS CORP. March 13, 2024 Shareholder proposal requesting a report on plant-based milk pricing.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Contested AGAINST
12 funds
Split
1 FOR, 8 AGAINST
SYSCO CORP. November 17, 2023 To consider a stockholder proposal related to re-establishing a policy for eliminating or reducing gestation crates in the Company's pork supply chain.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
2 FOR, 12 AGAINST
Split
7 FOR, 2 AGAINST
TESLA INC. June 13, 2024 A stockholder proposal regarding adoption of a freedom of association and collective bargaining policy, if properly presented.
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 8 AGAINST
Split
5 FOR, 4 AGAINST
TESLA INC. June 13, 2024 A stockholder proposal regarding annual reporting on anti-harassment and discrimination efforts, if properly presented.
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
11 funds
Split
4 FOR, 5 AGAINST
TEXAS ROADHOUSE INC. May 16, 2024 An Advisory Vote on a Shareholder Proposal Regarding the Issuance of a Climate Report.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 10 AGAINST
FOR
7 funds
THE TIMKEN COMPANY May 3, 2024 Consideration of a shareholder proposal requesting that The Timken Company adopt independently-verified short- and medium-term science-based greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets, inclusive of emissions from its full value chain, in order to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050 in line with the Paris Agreement's goal of limiting global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees Celsius
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
4 FOR, 16 AGAINST
FOR
7 funds
THE TJX COMPANIES, INC. June 4, 2024 Shareholder proposal for a report on effectiveness of social compliance efforts in TJX's supply chain
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
6 FOR, 7 AGAINST
THE TRAVELERS COMPANIES, INC. May 15, 2024 Shareholder proposal relating to CEO pay ratio and executive compensation, if presented at the Annual Meeting of Shareholders
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
19 funds
Split
1 FOR, 6 AGAINST
THE TRAVELERS COMPANIES, INC. May 15, 2024 Shareholder proposal relating to GHG emissions, if presented at the Annual Meeting of Shareholders
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
19 funds
Split
5 FOR, 2 AGAINST
THE TRAVELERS COMPANIES, INC. May 15, 2024 Shareholder proposal relating to a report on methane in the energy sector, if presented at the Annual Meeting of Shareholders
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
19 funds
Split
5 FOR, 2 AGAINST
THE TRAVELERS COMPANIES, INC. May 15, 2024 Shareholder proposal relating to human rights risks in underwriting, if presented at the Annual Meeting of Shareholders
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
19 funds
Split
5 FOR, 2 AGAINST
THE WENDY'S COMPANY May 21, 2024 Stockholder proposal regarding cage-free eggs, if properly presented at the Annual Meeting.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
2 FOR, 12 AGAINST
FOR
3 funds
TRUIST FINANCIAL CORP. April 23, 2024 Shareholder proposal regarding an annual report on lobbying activities, if properly presented at the Annual Meeting.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
10 FOR, 1 AGAINST
UNITED PARCEL SERVICE INC. May 2, 2024 To prepare an annual report on the effectiveness of UPS's diversity, equity and inclusion efforts.
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined Split
3 FOR, 13 AGAINST
Split
10 FOR, 3 AGAINST
UNITEDHEALTH GROUP INC. June 3, 2024 If properly presented at the 2024 Annual Meeting of Shareholders, the shareholder proposal requiring a political contributions congruency report.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
11 FOR, 15 AGAINST
VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC. May 9, 2024 Lead-sheathed cable report
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined AGAINST
19 funds
Split
13 FOR, 6 AGAINST
VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC. May 9, 2024 Lobbying activities report
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined AGAINST
19 funds
Split
15 FOR, 4 AGAINST
VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC. May 9, 2024 Political expenditures misalignment
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined AGAINST
19 funds
Split
13 FOR, 6 AGAINST
VERIZON COMMUNICATIONS INC. May 9, 2024 Prohibit political contributions study
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Not determined AGAINST
19 funds
Split
1 FOR, 18 AGAINST
VERTEX PHARMACEUTICALS INC. May 15, 2024 Shareholder proposal, if properly presented at the meeting, regarding a report on racial and gender pay gaps.
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
2 FOR, 11 AGAINST
Split
5 FOR, 5 AGAINST
WALGREENS BOOTS ALLIANCE INC. January 25, 2024 Stockholder proposal requesting a report on the risks of reproductive healthcare legislation.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
4 FOR, 2 AGAINST
WALMART INC. June 5, 2024 Publication of Targets for Transitioning from Gestation Crates in Pork Supply Chain
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
2 FOR, 13 AGAINST
Split
17 FOR, 2 AGAINST
WALMART INC. June 5, 2024 Racial Equity Audit
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
2 FOR, 17 AGAINST
WALMART INC. June 5, 2024 Workplace Safety & Violence Review
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
15 funds
Split
15 FOR, 4 AGAINST
WEIS MARKETS INC. May 2, 2024 Shareholder proposal requesting a report on how the Company is addressing climate-change related risks in its Supply Chain.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
4 FOR, 16 AGAINST
FOR
4 funds
WELLS FARGO & CO. April 30, 2024 Shareholder Proposal - Annual Report on Congruency of Political Spending and Corporate Values.
Other Social Issues
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
16 funds
Split
11 FOR, 7 AGAINST
WELLS FARGO & CO. April 30, 2024 Shareholder Proposal - Annual Report on Prevention of Workplace Harassment and Discrimination.
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 13 AGAINST
Split
2 FOR, 16 AGAINST
WELLS FARGO & CO. April 30, 2024 Shareholder Proposal - Third-Party Assessment of Respect for Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining.
Human Rights or Human Capital/workforce
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 13 AGAINST
Split
13 FOR, 5 AGAINST
WINGSTOP INC. May 23, 2024 Vote on a stockholder proposal regarding greenhouse gas emissions reporting and goals, if properly presented at the Annual Meeting of Stockholders; and
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against Split
3 FOR, 9 AGAINST
FOR
7 funds
YUM! BRANDS INC. May 16, 2024 Shareholder Proposal Regarding Adoption of a Policy on the Use of Medically Important Antimicrobials in Food-Producing Animals.
Environment or Climate
Shareholder (E&S) Against AGAINST
12 funds
Split
4 FOR, 4 AGAINST

← Previous Page 2 of 2

← All 20 managers, 2023-2024

How items are matched and positions counted: see the comparison table and the methodology. Built October 13, 2026 from SEC Form N-PX filings.