proxyvotesnow.com

Home › Asset managers › Compare 2023-2024 › Vanguard vs Brighthouse

Vanguard vs Brighthouse: how alike they voted, 2023-2024

91.9% When both took a single position, they voted the same way on 91.9% of 63,551 items (58,425 the same, 5,126 different). 12,130 items where at least one of them split its funds are listed separately below. Both voted on 75,681 items in all.

Note on Brighthouse: its funds did not all vote the same way on 11.4% of the 112,275 ballot items it voted. Those items are not in the percentage above; the ones it shares with this pair are listed under “Split votes”.

Vanguard 2023-2024 · Brighthouse 2023-2024 · Download the item list (CSV)

By who put the item on the ballot. “Same position” = Same / (Same + Differ); split items are not in it. “Fund-level” is a second view over all common items: the chance that a fund of each manager, picked at random, voted the same way, which gives partial credit where a manager split.
Common itemsSame DifferSplit (not in %)Same position Fund-level
All ballot items 75,68158,4255,126 12,13091.9%86.1%
Board proposals 63,74848,1904,731 10,82791.1%85.3%
E&S shareholder proposals 4881815 45554.5%33.5%
Other items 11,44510,217380 84896.4%93.3%

Where they did not vote alike

Everything Voted differently Split votes

All ballot items Board proposals E&S shareholder proposals Other items

17,256 items. “Voted differently”: each manager’s funds all voted one way, and the two ways differ. “Split”: at least one manager’s funds did not all vote the same way.

CompanyMeetingProposalOn the ballot from Board recommendedVanguardBrighthouse
KLABIN SA April 16, 2024 As an Ordinary Shareholder, Would You like to Request a Separate Minority Election of a Member of the Board of Directors, Under the Terms of Article 141 of the Brazilian Corporate Law?
Corporate Governance
Other None ABSTAIN
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
KLABIN SA April 16, 2024 Do You Wish to Adopt Cumulative Voting for the Election of the Members of the Board of Directors, Under the Terms of Article 141 of the Brazilian Corporate Law?
Shareholder Rights and Defenses
Other None FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
KLABIN SA April 16, 2024 Elect Directors (Slate 2 Proposed by Shareholder)
Director Elections
Other None FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
KLABIN SA April 16, 2024 In Case Neither Class of Shares Reaches the Minimum Quorum Required by the Brazilian Corporate Law to Elect a Board Representative in Separate Elections, Would You Like to Use Your Votes to Elect the Candidate with More Votes to Represent Both Classes?
Corporate Governance
Other None FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
KOHL'S CORP. May 15, 2024 Shareholder Proposal - Corporate Financial Substantiality Report
Corporate Governance
Other Against AGAINST
17 funds
ABSTAIN
4 funds
KOMERI CO. LTD. June 21, 2024 Amend Articles to Restore Shareholder Authority to Vote on Income Allocation and Share Buybacks
Capital Structure
Other Against AGAINST
7 funds
FOR
1 fund
KUMAGAI GUMI CO. LTD. June 27, 2024 Approve Additional Allocation of Income so that Final Dividend per Share Equals to JPY 160
Capital Structure
Other Against AGAINST
5 funds
FOR
1 fund
KUNLUN ENERGY COMPANY LTD. November 16, 2023 Approve New Master Agreement, Non-Exempt Continuing Connected Transactions, Proposed Annual Caps and Related Transactions
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
KUSURI NO AOKI HOLDINGS CO. LTD. August 17, 2023 Amend Articles to Appoint Lead Independent Director
Corporate Governance
Other Against AGAINST
5 funds
FOR
1 fund
KUSURI NO AOKI HOLDINGS CO. LTD. August 17, 2023 Amend Articles to Establish Advisory Nominating and Compensation Committee
Corporate Governance
Other Against AGAINST
5 funds
FOR
1 fund
KWEICHOW MOUTAI CO. LTD. May 29, 2024 Approve Daily Related Party Transactions
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
2 funds
KYOKUTO KAIHATSU KOGYO CO. LTD. June 26, 2024 Approve Additional Dividend so that Dividend Equals to Either 100 Percent of Earnings per Share or 6 Percent of Net Asset per Share whichever Is Higher
Capital Structure
Other Against AGAINST
6 funds
FOR
1 fund
LEONARDO SPA May 24, 2024 Amend Company Bylaws Re: Article 18.4
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
4 funds
LIBERTY GLOBAL PLC July 13, 2023 To Approve The Shareholders Meeting Adjournment Resolution, A Proposal To Approve The Adjournment Of The Shareholders Meeting, If Necessary, To Solicit Additional Votes If There Are Insufficient Votes In Favor Of The Advisory Resolutions.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
1 fund
ABSTAIN
1 fund
LINK & MOTIVATION INC. March 28, 2024 Amend Articles to Allow Virtual Only Shareholder Meetings - Establish Record Dates for Quarterly Dividends
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
LIVANOVA PLC June 11, 2024 Ordinary Resolution: To receive and adopt the Companys audited UK statutory accounts for the year ended December 31, 2023, together with the reports of the directors and auditors thereon.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
2 funds
ABSTAIN
2 funds
LYONDELLBASELL INDUSTRIES NV May 24, 2024 Adoption of 2023 Dutch Statutory Annual Accounts.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
2 funds
ABSTAIN
7 funds
LYONDELLBASELL INDUSTRIES NV May 24, 2024 Discharge of Directors from Liability.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
2 funds
ABSTAIN
7 funds
MAXSCEND MICROELECTRONICS CO. LTD. May 20, 2024 Amend External Guarantee Management System
Corporate Governance
Other For AGAINST
5 funds
ABSTAIN
1 fund
MAXSCEND MICROELECTRONICS CO. LTD. May 20, 2024 Amend Information Disclosure Management Measures
Corporate Governance
Other For AGAINST
5 funds
ABSTAIN
1 fund
MAXSCEND MICROELECTRONICS CO. LTD. May 20, 2024 Amend Raised Funds Management System
Corporate Governance
Other For AGAINST
5 funds
ABSTAIN
1 fund
MAXSCEND MICROELECTRONICS CO. LTD. May 20, 2024 Amend Working System for Independent Directors
Corporate Governance
Other For AGAINST
5 funds
ABSTAIN
1 fund
MEDIAALPHA INC. May 16, 2024 To approve an amendment to our Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation to reflect new Delaware law provisions regarding officer exculpation; and
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
14 funds
AGAINST
2 funds
MERIDIANLINK INC. June 6, 2024 Approval of amendment to the Company's Certificate of Incorporation to allow for the exculpation of officers.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
11 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
MERIDIANLINK INC. June 6, 2024 Approval of the adjournment of the annual meeting to the extent there are insufficient votes at the annual meeting to approve any of proposals 1-4.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
11 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
MERUS NV May 7, 2024 Articles Amendment B - Approval of the amendment of the Articles of Association to reflect the Large Company Regime and authorization to implement such amendment.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
2 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
MIDDLE EAST HEALTHCARE CO. June 13, 2024 Approve Discharge of Directors for FY 2023
Corporate Governance
Other For AGAINST
3 funds
FOR
1 fund
MINTH GROUP LTD. October 31, 2023 Amend Articles of Association in Line with the Amendments Made to the Applicable Laws of the Cayman Islands and the Listing Rules, Modernize Certain Provisions and Incorporate Certain Consequential and Housekeeping Amendments
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
MIXI INC. June 26, 2024 Amend Articles to Allow Virtual Only Shareholder Meetings
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
MOBILE TELECOMMUNICATIONS CO. KSCP May 6, 2024 Approve Discharge of Directors for FY 2023
Corporate Governance
Other For AGAINST
4 funds
FOR
1 fund
MONCLER SPA April 24, 2024 Accounts and Reports
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
1 fund
ABSTAIN
1 fund
MOTOR OIL (HELLAS) CORINTH REFINERIES SA January 24, 2024 Approve the Acquisition of 25 Percent of the Share Capital of ANEMOS RES SA by the Subsidiary MOTOR OIL RENEWABLE ENERGY SINGLE MEMBER SA from ELLAKTOR SA; and the Signing of the Relevant Draft of the Share Purchase Agreement
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
MULLEN AUTOMOTIVE INC. February 29, 2024 To approve the adjournment of the annual meeting from time to time, to a later date or dates, if necessary or appropriate, under certain circumstances, including for the purpose of soliciting additional proxies in favor one or more of the foregoing proposals, in the event the Company does not receive the requisite stockholder vote to approve such proposal(s) or establish a quorum.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
3 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
MURPHY USA INC. May 9, 2024 Stockholder Proposal-Simple Majority Vote
Corporate Governance
Other Against AGAINST
25 funds
FOR
5 funds
MYTILINEOS SA June 4, 2024 Change Company Name
Corporate Governance
Other For AGAINST
5 funds
FOR
1 fund
NANJING IRON & STEEL CO. LTD. June 20, 2024 Approve Signing of Financial Services Agreement and Related Party Transaction
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NANO-X IMAGING LTD. June 25, 2024 Elect Erez Meltzer, CEO, as Chairman
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NERDWALLET INC. May 14, 2024 To amend the Company's Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation to reflect new Delaware law provisions regarding officer exculpation.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
10 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NEW ORIENTAL EDUCATION & TECHNOLOGY GROUP INC. November 28, 2023 Adopt Third Amended and Restated Memorandum of Association and Articles of Association
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NEXITY SA May 23, 2024 Delegate Powers to the Board to Amend Bylaws to Comply with Legal Changes
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
7 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NHK SPRING CO. LTD. June 25, 2024 Approve Restricted Stock Plan
Compensation
Other Against AGAINST
7 funds
FOR
1 fund
NINETY ONE PLC July 26, 2023 Approve Climate Strategy
Environment or Climate
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NIPPON SIGNAL CO. LTD. June 21, 2024 Amend Articles to Amend Provisions on Number of Directors
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NISSAN SHATAI CO. LTD. June 26, 2024 Amend Articles to Establish Minority Shareholder Protection Committee
Corporate Governance
Other Against AGAINST
6 funds
FOR
1 fund
NOKIA CORP. April 3, 2024 Amendments to Articles Regarding Company Object
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
3 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NOKIA CORP. April 3, 2024 Amendments to Articles Regarding Virtual Only Meetings
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
3 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORP. May 9, 2024 Election of Directors - NOMINEE OPPOSED BY THE COMPANY: Sameh Fahmy
Director Elections
Other Contested WITHHOLD
2 funds
FOR
1 fund
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORP. May 9, 2024 Election of Directors - NOMINEE OPPOSED BY THE COMPANY: William Clyburn, Jr.
Director Elections
Other Contested WITHHOLD
2 funds
FOR
1 fund
NORFOLK SOUTHERN CORP. May 9, 2024 The Ancora Bylaw Proposal to repeal any provision or amendment of Norfolk Southern's Bylaws adopted by the Board without shareholder approval after July 25, 2023, if properly presented.
Corporate Governance
Other Contested AGAINST
2 funds
FOR
1 fund
NORTHWEST HEALTHCARE PROPERTIES REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUST June 18, 2024 Amend Declaration of Trust
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NOVARTIS AG March 5, 2024 Elect Patrice Bula as Compensation Committee Member
Compensation
Other For FOR
3 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
NXP SEMICONDUCTORS NV May 29, 2024 Adoption of the 2023 Statutory Annual Accounts.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
9 funds
ABSTAIN
2 funds
OLO INC. June 20, 2024 To approve an amendment to our Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation to limit the liability of certain officers as permitted by Delaware law.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
14 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
PARAMOUNT GLOBAL June 4, 2024 A stockholder proposal, if properly presented at the meeting, requesting that our Board of Directors take steps to adopt a policy to require stockholder approval of certain "golden parachute" compensation packages.
Compensation
Other Against AGAINST
11 funds
FOR
1 fund
PARAMOUNT GLOBAL June 4, 2024 The amendment and restatement of the Company's Certificate of incorporation, primarily to provide for officer exculpation under Delaware law.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
11 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
PENNON GROUP PLC July 20, 2023 Approve Climate-Related Financial Disclosures
Environment or Climate
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
PERELLA WEINBERG PARTNERS May 22, 2024 To approve an amendment to the Company's Restated Certificate of Incorporation to update the exculpation provision.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
9 funds
AGAINST
4 funds
PETROCHINA COMPANY LTD. June 5, 2024 Approve Report of the Board of Directors
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
2 funds
PETROLEO BRASILEIRO SA November 30, 2023 In the Event of a Second Call, Can the Voting Instructions Contained in this Proxy Card Be Considered Valid for the Second Call?
Corporate Governance
Other None FOR
4 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
PETROLEO BRASILEIRO SA April 25, 2024 Do You Wish to Adopt Cumulative Voting for the Election of the Members of the Board of Directors, Under the Terms of Article 141 of the Brazilian Corporate Law?
Shareholder Rights and Defenses
Other None FOR
4 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
PETROLEO BRASILEIRO SA April 25, 2024 In the Event of a Second Call, Can the Voting Instructions Contained in this Proxy Card Be Considered Valid for the Second Call?
Corporate Governance
Other None FOR
4 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
PING AN INSURANCE May 30, 2024 TO CONSIDER AND APPROVE THE RESOLUTION REGARDING THE AMENDMENTS TO THE ARTICLES OF ASSOCIATION
Corporate Governance
Other Not determined FOR
1 fund
AGAINST
1 fund
PLAYSTUDIOS INC. June 4, 2024 Approval and adoption of an amendment to the Certificate of Incorporation of PLAYSTUDIOS, Inc. to reflect recent changes in Delaware law regarding the exculpation of officers.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
8 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
POLYPLEX CORPORATION LTD. October 30, 2023 Adopt Amended and Restated Articles of Association
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
POSTE ITALIANE SPA May 31, 2024 Amend Company Bylaws Re: Article 16
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
7 funds
AGAINST
3 funds
PRADA SPA April 24, 2024 Elect Lorenzo Bertelli as Director
Director Elections
Other For AGAINST
6 funds
FOR
1 fund
PRADA SPA April 24, 2024 Elect Marina Sylvia Caprotti as Director
Director Elections
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
PRADA SPA April 24, 2024 Elect Paolo Zannoni as Director
Director Elections
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
PRADA SPA April 24, 2024 Elect Yoel Zaoui as Director
Director Elections
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
PRASHKOVSKY INVESTMENTS & CONSTRUCTION LTD. October 24, 2023 Authorize Board Chairman to Serve as CEO
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
1 fund
AGAINST
1 fund
PUBMATIC INC. May 31, 2024 To approve an amendment to our Restated Certificate of incorporation to permit the exculpation of officers.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
13 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
QIAGEN NV June 21, 2024 Proposal to adopt the Annual Accounts for the year ended December 31, 2023 ( Calendar Year 2023 ).
Corporate Governance
Other Not determined FOR
1 fund
ABSTAIN
1 fund
QIAGEN NV June 21, 2024 Proposal to cast a favorable non-binding advisory vote in respect of the Remuneration Report 2023.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
1 fund
ABSTAIN
1 fund
QIAGEN NV June 21, 2024 Proposal to discharge from liability the Managing Directors for the performance of their duties during Calendar Year 2023.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
1 fund
ABSTAIN
1 fund
QIAGEN NV June 21, 2024 Proposal to discharge from liability the Supervisory Directors for the performance of their duties during Calendar Year 2023.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
1 fund
ABSTAIN
1 fund
RACCOON HOLDINGS INC. July 22, 2023 Amend Articles to Allow Virtual Only Shareholder Meetings
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
REDES ENERGETICAS NACIONAIS SGPS SA May 9, 2024 Elect Corporate Bodies for 2024-2026 Term
Director Elections
Other None FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
REPLY SPA April 23, 2024 Elect Mario Rizzante as Board Chair
Director Elections
Other None FOR
7 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
RESTAURANT BRANDS INTERNATIONAL INC. June 6, 2024 Consider a shareholder proposal to require Board Chair to be independent.
Corporate Governance
Other Against AGAINST
7 funds
FOR
1 fund
ROCKET COMPANIES INC. June 18, 2024 Approval of the amendment to Rocket's Certificate of Incorporation to provide officer exculpation as permitted under Delaware law.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
16 funds
AGAINST
2 funds
RYOBI LTD. March 27, 2024 Amend Articles to Allow Virtual Only Shareholder Meetings
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SALVATORE FERRAGAMO SPA April 23, 2024 Deliberations Pursuant to Article 2390 of Civil Code Re: Decisions Inherent to Authorization of Board Members to Assume Positions in Competing Companies
Corporate Governance
Other None FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SAMSUNG C&T CORP. March 15, 2024 Approve Appropriation of Income (KRW 4,500 per Common Share and KRW 4,550 per Preferred Share) (Shareholder Proposal)
Capital Structure
Other Against AGAINST
6 funds
FOR
1 fund
SAMSUNG C&T CORP. March 15, 2024 Approve Financial Statements
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
6 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SAO MARTINHO SA July 28, 2023 In the Event of a Second Call, the Voting Instructions Contained in this Remote Voting Card May Also be Considered for the Second Call?
Corporate Governance
Other None FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SAUDI ARABIAN MINING CO. May 13, 2024 Amend Articles of Bylaws According to the New Companies' Law, and Rearranging the Articles of Bylaws in Accordance with the Proposed Amendments
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
4 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SAUDI ARABIAN OIL CO. May 6, 2024 Amend Article 18 of Bylaws Re: Remuneration of the Board
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
3 funds
AGAINST
2 funds
SEMRUSH HOLDINGS INC. June 6, 2024 A proposal to approve an amendment to our Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation to limit the liability of certain officers of Semrush Holdings, Inc. as permitted by recent amendments to the Delaware General Corporation Law.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
11 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SHAANXI COAL INDUSTRY CO. LTD. June 13, 2024 Approve Related Party Transactions
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SHANXI COAL INTERNATIONAL ENERGY GROUP CO. LTD. April 26, 2024 Approve Related Party Transaction
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
4 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SHANXI LU'AN ENVIRONMENTAL ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CO. LTD. May 29, 2024 Approve Provision of Financial Service
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SHANXI LU'AN ENVIRONMENTAL ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CO. LTD. May 29, 2024 Approve Related Party Transaction
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SHIZUOKA GAS CO. LTD. March 27, 2024 Amend Articles to Amend Provisions on Number of Directors
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
7 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SICHUAN CHANGHONG ELECTRIC CO. LTD. December 29, 2023 Approve Related Party Transaction with Sichuan Changhong Electronics Holding Group Co., Ltd.
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
4 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SICHUAN CHANGHONG ELECTRIC CO. LTD. December 29, 2023 Approve Signing of Financial Service Agreement
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
4 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SIEMENS AG February 8, 2024 Ratify Kasper Rorsted
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
8 funds
ABSTAIN
1 fund
SIGMAXYZ HOLDINGS INC. June 25, 2024 Amend Articles to Amend Provisions on Number of Directors
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
5 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SINOPHARM GROUP CO. LTD. December 20, 2023 Approve 2023 Financial Services Framework Agreement, Proposed Maximum Daily Balances of the Deposit Services and Related Transactions
Corporate Governance
Other For FOR
7 funds
AGAINST
1 fund
SLC AGRICOLA SA April 29, 2024 Do You Wish to Request Installation of a Fiscal Council, Under the Terms of Article 161 of the Brazilian Corporate Law?
Corporate Governance
Other None ABSTAIN
5 funds
FOR
1 fund
SMITH & WESSON BRANDS INC. September 19, 2023 A stockholder proposal (right to call special shareholder meeting).
Corporate Governance
Other Against AGAINST
10 funds
FOR
1 fund

← Previous Page 3 of 173 Next →

← All 20 managers, 2023-2024

How items are matched and positions counted: see the comparison table and the methodology. Built October 13, 2026 from SEC Form N-PX filings.